> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.the-scientists-notebook.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Snippet #040: Why the Same Training Produces Such Different Results
- URL: https://www.the-scientists-notebook.com/why-the-same-training-produces-such-different-results/
- Published: 2026-10-16T09:00:08.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-28T11:57:00.000Z
- Author: Thomas Mortelmans
- Tags: science, snippet, physiology

**Give hundreds of sedentary adults the same 20-week aerobic program and the spread of outcomes is striking.**

In the HERITAGE Family Study, the average gain in maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max, a measure of how much oxygen the body can use at peak effort) was **roughly 400 ml/min**.

But the range ran from near zero to more than a liter per minute.

Bouchard and colleagues found about 2.5 times more of that variation between families than within them, pointing to a **maximal heritability estimate of 47%** for VO2max trainability ([Bouchard et al. 1999](https://doi.org/10.1152/jappl.1999.87.3.1003?ref=the-scientists-notebook.com)).

![In the HERITAGE Family Study, the VO2max gain from one program varied 2.5 times more between families than within them.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d0/c6/d0c6e306-bed3-4c90-ab90-46af32dc89c6/content/images/2026/10/fig-hero-27.png)

This matters because **group averages routinely bury individual biology**.

A person who sees a modest VO2max gain from a standard endurance block is not necessarily a [poor responder](https://www.the-scientists-notebook.com/entry-011-genetic-variability-in-vo2max-responses-and-what-it-means-for-individualized-training/) to training as a whole.

The paper analyzed only oxygen uptake, so it says nothing about strength, movement economy, or power output.

**Low VO2max trainability reflects one trait, not overall athletic potential.**

Heritability describes variation across a group, **not how much of one person's gain comes from genes**.

The study tested one standardized program, so it cannot say how training volume, intensity, or method would shift an individual's gain.

---

If you have 60 seconds, I would value your anonymous feedback. You can share it [here](https://forms.gle/9BJy78gBpszUnoY76?ref=the-scientists-notebook.com).

---

### Health disclaimer

> This summarizes one study of 481 sedentary white adults from 98 families on one 20-week program. It cannot say how any one person would respond, and it is not training advice. Not medical advice.

[VO2max: Maximal Aerobic CapacityVO2max (maximal oxygen uptake) is the gold-standard measure of aerobic fitness: the maximum rate at which an individual can transport and utilize oxygen during exercise. Expressed in milliliters of oxygen per kilogram of body mass per minute (mL/kg/min), VO2max sets the ceiling for aerobic performan![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d0/c6/d0c6e306-bed3-4c90-ab90-46af32dc89c6/content/images/icon/Kopie-van-logo---Copy-9ef0a4b8-6c84-40b6-81e6-93148cb124f0.jpeg)The Scientist’s NotebookThomas Mortelmans![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d0/c6/d0c6e306-bed3-4c90-ab90-46af32dc89c6/content/images/2026/02/Generated-Image-February-22--2026---2_20PM.jpeg)](https://www.the-scientists-notebook.com/vo2max/)

[Snippet #034: Minutes Near the Ceiling: Why Interval Sessions Count Time Near VO2maxVO2max is the ceiling on how fast the body can use oxygen. Sport scientists have grown interested in time near VO2max as a way to describe interval sessions. Buchheit and Laursen (2013) note that it is believed an optimal stimulus for maximal cardiovascular and peripheral (muscle) adaptation is at l![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d0/c6/d0c6e306-bed3-4c90-ab90-46af32dc89c6/content/images/icon/Kopie-van-logo---Copy-9ef0a4b8-6c84-40b6-81e6-93148cb124f0.jpeg)The Scientist’s NotebookThomas Mortelmans![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d0/c6/d0c6e306-bed3-4c90-ab90-46af32dc89c6/content/images/2026/10/fig-hero-10.png)](https://www.the-scientists-notebook.com/minutes-near-the-ceiling-why-time-at-vo2max-shapes-aerobic-adaptation/)

Related reading

[Snippet #027: Your Energy Systems Run Together, Not in SequenceThe aerobic and oxygen-independent pathways of energy production operate simultaneously from the first second of exercise. Their relative share shifts continuously with intensity and duration; it is a dial, not a switch. In reviewed studies of all-out effort, the aerobic system already supplies roug![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d0/c6/d0c6e306-bed3-4c90-ab90-46af32dc89c6/content/images/icon/Kopie-van-logo---Copy-9ef0a4b8-6c84-40b6-81e6-93148cb124f0.jpeg)The Scientist’s NotebookThomas Mortelmans![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d0/c6/d0c6e306-bed3-4c90-ab90-46af32dc89c6/content/images/2026/10/fig-hero-12.png)](https://www.the-scientists-notebook.com/your-energy-systems-run-together-not-in-sequence/)

Related reading

---

### Keep going

Gradescale turns your training history into the models in this piece: power-duration, load balance, and readiness, each with its sources.

[Open Gradescale ](https://gradescale.fit/?ref=the-scientists-notebook.com) 

Training plans built on the same evidence base:

[ESQ.Coaching - Training PlansMost athletes do not plateau from a lack of effort. Structured, evidence-led plans built on the Endurance Science Quest philosophy.![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d0/c6/d0c6e306-bed3-4c90-ab90-46af32dc89c6/content/images/icon/Kopie-van-logo---Copy-9ef0a4b8-6c84-40b6-81e6-93148cb124f0.jpeg)The Scientist’s NotebookThomas Mortelmans](https://www.the-scientists-notebook.com/trainon/)

Join our **Discord community**:

[ESQ.DiscordConnect your newsletter subscription to access the community.![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d0/c6/d0c6e306-bed3-4c90-ab90-46af32dc89c6/content/images/icon/Kopie-van-logo---Copy-9ef0a4b8-6c84-40b6-81e6-93148cb124f0.jpeg)The Scientist’s NotebookThomas Mortelmans](https://www.the-scientists-notebook.com/join-discord/)

## Sign up for The Scientist’s Notebook

Evidence-first endurance science, in your inbox. No hype, sources every time.

Subscribe 

Check your inbox and confirm your subscription. 

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.