Skip to content
4 min read

Snippet #040: Why the Same Training Produces Such Different Results

Snippet #040: Why the Same Training Produces Such Different Results

Give hundreds of sedentary adults the same 20-week aerobic program and the spread of outcomes is striking.

In the HERITAGE Family Study, the average gain in maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max, a measure of how much oxygen the body can use at peak effort) was roughly 400 ml/min.

But the range ran from near zero to more than a liter per minute.

Bouchard and colleagues found about 2.5 times more of that variation between families than within them, pointing to a maximal heritability estimate of 47% for VO2max trainability (Bouchard et al. 1999).

In the HERITAGE Family Study, the VO2max gain from one program varied 2.5 times more between families than within them.

This matters because group averages routinely bury individual biology.

A person who sees a modest VO2max gain from a standard endurance block is not necessarily a poor responder to training as a whole.

The paper analyzed only oxygen uptake, so it says nothing about strength, movement economy, or power output.

Low VO2max trainability reflects one trait, not overall athletic potential.

Heritability describes variation across a group, not how much of one person's gain comes from genes.

The study tested one standardized program, so it cannot say how training volume, intensity, or method would shift an individual's gain.


If you have 60 seconds, I would value your anonymous feedback. You can share it here.


Health disclaimer

This summarizes one study of 481 sedentary white adults from 98 families on one 20-week program. It cannot say how any one person would respond, and it is not training advice. Not medical advice.
VO2max: Maximal Aerobic Capacity
VO2max (maximal oxygen uptake) is the gold-standard measure of aerobic fitness: the maximum rate at which an individual can transport and utilize oxygen during exercise. Expressed in milliliters of oxygen per kilogram of body mass per minute (mL/kg/min), VO2max sets the ceiling for aerobic performan
Snippet #034: Minutes Near the Ceiling: Why Interval Sessions Count Time Near VO2max
VO2max is the ceiling on how fast the body can use oxygen. Sport scientists have grown interested in time near VO2max as a way to describe interval sessions. Buchheit and Laursen (2013) note that it is believed an optimal stimulus for maximal cardiovascular and peripheral (muscle) adaptation is at l
Related reading
Snippet #027: Your Energy Systems Run Together, Not in Sequence
The aerobic and oxygen-independent pathways of energy production operate simultaneously from the first second of exercise. Their relative share shifts continuously with intensity and duration; it is a dial, not a switch. In reviewed studies of all-out effort, the aerobic system already supplies roug
Related reading

Keep going

Training plans built on the same evidence base:

ESQ.Coaching - Training Plans
Most athletes do not plateau from a lack of effort. Structured, evidence-led plans built on the Endurance Science Quest philosophy.

Join our Discord community:

ESQ.Discord
Connect your newsletter subscription to access the community.

Found this useful?

Get articles like this and free training calculators in your inbox every week.

Recommended reads

If this was useful, these are the other research-driven newsletters I actually read.

Open the list